Showing posts with label Eric Grannis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Eric Grannis. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

How Charter Schools Are Only "Public" In That They Feed at the Public Trough

Here is a fact sheet being distributed in Williamsburg/Greenpoint on Eric Grannis' charter that will "compete" with his wife Eva Moskowitz' charters. Email me for the pdf if you want to share.

Citizens of the World Charter Schools
are trying to open TWO privately managed charter schools into our district. They intend to move into our public schools, draw white middle class kids away from our schools and into theirs (with enrollment targets of 55% white families), and take away our valuable art rooms, science labs, music rooms, computer labs, and mixed space for special needs kids. When you scratch beneath the surface of the glossy marketing, are these proposals offering anything new or different?
What do Public Schools offer vs. the proposed Charter Schools?
The Neighborhood Public Schools
Citizens of the World Charter Schools
Project-based Learning
Yes
Yes
Constructivist Learning models with Differentiated Instruction
Yes
Yes
Ongoing robust assessment of children’s learning for ongoing academic interventions
Yes
Yes
Balanced Literacy including leveled library, Workshop Model and Writing Curriculum out of Teachers College
Yes
Yes
Authentic literature in the classroom
Yes
NO
Service learning and integration of meaningful community service with classroom curriculum
Yes
Yes
Community building within the school community including character education, respect for diversity, and addressing the “whole child” with attention to the social and emotional development of children.
Yes
Yes
Arts threaded through the Curriculum
Yes
Yes
Parents involvement in shaping school budget
Yes
NO
Parents involvement in the evaluation and assessment of educational programs
Yes
NO
Teachers with more than 3 years Experience
Yes
NO
Teachers with Masters Degrees +30 hours
Yes
NO
Principals with more than 10 years of leadership/classroom experience
Yes
NO
Regular job-embedded professional development for teachers including Backwards Planning, technology in the classroom, and re-directing reluctant learners.
Yes
Yes
Casual policy to hold back children in grades K-3 (grade retention)
NO
Yes
A commitment to educate EVERY child in the community
Yes
NO
email williamsburggreenpointschools@gmail facebook www.facebook.com/WilliamsburgGreenpointParents

CEC 14 Hearing against Citizens of the World Charter School --Videos and More

We published a report on this hearing last week: Report from the Hearing on Citizens of the World C... and here is the video from Pat Dobosz (GEM/ICE/MORE).
 
 
Introductions of CEC 14 members. Carrie Marlin of the Division of Portfolio Planning introduces PS 19 network leader, Margarita Nell.
 
 
Congresswoman Nydia Velazquez
 
Carrie Marlin responds to Congresswoman Nydia Velazquez
 
 
Senior Supervising Superintendent, Donald Conyers
 
CEC member, Elaine Manatu: No one can give us answers...
 
 
Divisionof Portfolio Planning, Carrie Marlin and her data.
 
 
Carrie Marlin and leader selection, Charter pipeline possibilities for Brooklyn.
 
 
CEC 14 member Elaine Manatu: It doesn't seem like feedback. It feels like an announcement.
 
 
Mr. Donald Conyers speaks about the late Superintendent, Fortunato Rubino and insults parents. he has been in the system for 29 years and only taught for five of those years!
 
 
DOE Rep, Jessica speaks about what charters are and introduces Citizens of the World.
 
 
Kate Sobel, Board member of Citizens of the World Charter School is given a not-so welcome Williamsburg reception.
 
 
Congresswoman Nydia Velazquez: We do not need more elementary schools. Who are you fooling DOE?
 
 
Assemblyman Joe Lentol: We have public education going on here that is great public education.
 
 
State Committeeman, Lincoln Restler: ...the DOE has one priority...imposing charter schools in each and every school.
 
 
Mr. Juan Martinez: We consider ourselves part of a special family here in District 14. Let's not make this a done deal.
 
 
Maria Bautista representing Councilwoman Diana Reyna: We do not want any more charter schools in this district.
 
 
Jason Otono, Special Assistant for Legal Affairs to Brooklyn Borough President, Marty Markowitz: The office of the Borough President is opposed to any Citizens of the World Charter Schools in District 14.
 
 
Representative of Councilman Steven Levin: CM Levein is staunchly against this proposal...
 
 
Brooke Parker parent speaking on behalf of all the parents/ schools represented in tour district: Accepting these two Citizens of the World Charter School proposals will segregate our schools.
 
 
Brook Parker continues with the consent of the audience...
 
20120419071907 CEC 14 Hearing] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cL4JUIoqYCg
 
PS 132 parent, Sarah Porter, asked Mr. Conyers to attend the PTA meetings at every single school and learn about what is going on.
 
[20120419072218 CEC 14 Hearing] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xr1QPHOUX7U
 
PS 132 Parent, Sarah Porter on the PS 19 phase out and leadership


Thank you EVERYONE for coming to the Hearing on Thursday!  It was a terrific turnout, particularly considering how many other important forums and Hearings were happening that same night.  And a heartfelt thanks to our elected representatives for really representing!  
It is time for each of us to write individual emails (and get others to write!)  to the SUNY Charter School Institute regarding the Citizens of the World proposals.   Please pass this along to your respective groups and ask them to send some emails as well. 

Enclosed the 22 page comments on the proposal for you to draw from for inspiration.
[Email normsco@gmail.com for a copy].

We need to write as MANY emails as we can from as many people as we can saying as many different things as we can.

I encourage our spanish speaking members to write their emails in Spanish.  Or, write in any other language if you like.
You are welcome to pull directly from the comments.  
PLEASE blind copy williamsburggreenpointschools@gmail.com so that we can keep a copy of your letter.

Here's an example of an email.  Cut and paste as needed, but make it your own by adding information from the comments:

Dear Suny Charter Schools Institute:

I am opposed to the two Citizens of the World Charter Schools proposals designed for District 14.

Regardless of whether these two proposed schools intend to co-locate in our public schools, our district simply does not need any more elementary schools.  Adding more choice for the sake of choice will undermine the quality of the public schools that we currently enjoy.

Our district is not suffering from a lack of options for elementary schools.  We have eight elementary magnet schools, our unzoned schools have room for out of zone kids, and, by the Fall of 2013, we will have eight elementary charter schools.  The UCLA Civil Rights Project has a recent report underlining  magnet schools as a successful model distinct from charter schools.  We believe that these proposed schools will jeopardize any hope we have of achieving diversity in our four new magnets for elementary schools and will undermine the promise that the NYC DoE made to the federal government to address socio-economic and racial isolation in those schools and our district.

The proposals for Citizens of the World reflects the minimum amount of work that they did to understand our district.  They did not mention our magnet schools at all. No one involved in their proposal had even the vaguest understanding of the choices already available in our district.  These two proposed schools do not offer anything unique in the way of curriculum, programming, or pedagogy.  CWSNY1 and CWSNY2 are copies of the schools that we have.

I am also concerned that.....

Regards,

Name
Address
 

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

The Harlem Success Tries to Turn White as the Worm Keeps Turning - Eva's Hubby Gets Into the Act

Gotham: Eric Grannis, charter board member and Eva Moskowitz’s husband:
Charters should integrate. (Daily News)

Michael Fiorillo
Grannis' piece in the Daily News is nothing more than transparent attempt to justify his wife's invasion of the Brandeis HS building on the Upper West Side. In other words, the usual charter operator's dissembling and deceptive use of civil rights rhetoric in service of privatization.
I go further than Michael. HSA is ready to move to the white middle class where test scores come easy. My racism detector has been activated. Just like I reported the other day when Eva (rich white woman) organized poor Black people to oppose the NAACP law suit against closing schools and charter co-locos. (Eric Grannis supposedly reads ed notes so he should be happy to see his name in print.)
Maybe we'd serve minority students better if, instead of creating good schools for minorities to make up for the bad schools minorities have had for so long, we just created good schools for everyone. As the Supreme Court has said, "he way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race."
Gee, Eric, how disingenuous of you. If you wanted to integrate your charter schools why don't you offer buses to all those white parents who want to attend HSA and bus them into Harlem at your local HSA schools there. Let's see how attractive the white parents consider your schools then. Or is it just about Brandeis or Bust?

I posted a video over the weekend where you can see the new (white) faces HSA is looking for snickering at the Brandeis HS press conference where parents and community opposed the HSA takeover of whole sections of public real estate. What next Eric, HSA condos?

Brandeis HS - Opposing HSA Invasion - May 26, 2011
A PS 241 teacher describes the impact on her school from having a Harlem Success Academy school in her building. I challenged and captured some comments from HSA future parents, the face of the attempt to gentrify charter schools on the upper west side.

http://youtu.be/iYhH-hsztn4

Also this video of Julie Cavanagh savaging charters:

http://youtu.be/frIajrQfgUo 

For those of you who don't read the comments, here is a very valuable follow-up:
Michael Fiorillo said...
Norm, you are are absolutely right: one of the unspoken dynamics in charter expansion in NYC is that they are a real estate play. Whether it is the expropriating of public school facilities, or as a prelude and anchor for further gentrification of communities (i.e. Gideon Stein, Success Charter Network Board member, and head of Argyle Holdings, "Developers of premier properties in Northern Manhattan").

As with Geoffrey Canada's incursion into the St. Nicolas Houses, while public housing units all over the city are being allowed to become run-down and (reputedly) units are being warehoused, the people pushing these schools are also tightly aligned with real estate and urban redevelopment interests in rapidly gentrifying neighborhoods. It's possible that, rhetoric and PR aside, this is what Grannis has in mind when he writes about "integrating" charters schools: at current rates of demographic change, Harlem and Bed-Stuy will be increasingly white neighborhoods. Maybe the black families being recruited are just placeholders until the neighborhood "tips" sufficiently. Of course, even then you will still see the faces of adorable black children on all the 4-color, glossy promotional materials.

Finance and real estate, the twin electromagnetic poles of urban political juice, see mutual benefits from charter expansion. They continue to grow because, despite the fact that they are educationally inferior to public schools and an economic drain and diversion away from them, they represent a coalition of powerful interests.

Remember "synergy," a Wall Street/consultant/B-School buzz word from a decade or more ago? The idea was that assembling disparate companies would lead to new opportunities and dynamism within the whole.

That's some of what's going on with elite support for charter schools, the hoped-for synergy of corporate control of school management, curriculum, instruction, labor relations and infrastructure. It's a gold mine for them, and cold, watery soup for everyone else.

It's happening right now. And it's accelerating.