A List of 222 School Level Chapter Leaders Running for Unity: Loyalty Oathers Who Will Sell You Out When Told To

Some people ask me who are the 750 Unity delegates that will elected and will get the perks of the Unity patronage machine with free trips and union job offers.

THE JOKE OF THE WEEK

Thanks to the work of Jonathan Halabi for putting together a list of all Unity people who are running -- 222 Unity CLs from the schools are running in the election (the list may not be complete and I am not including CLs from functional chapters).

They are part of the 750-800 who will go to this July's AFT convention in Minneapolis (we will publish some more including district reps and other in the future), all expenses paid by our dues, to vote as ONE for anything Randi and Mulgrew wants them to vote for. They will also go to the NYSUT convention next April and stay at the NY Hilton to make sure Unity keeps control against any challenge from Stronger Together. Also on our dues.

When the 2018 contract comes up for a vote, no matter how onerous it is, they will sell it to the members of their schools. They owe their loyalty to Unity and the UFT leadership, not the members who elected them. Now there are even more Unity CLs and some delegates who are not running for election. Who knows exactly hoe many CLs and delegates they have - and if you add functionals and retirees (300) they have the DA under control - unless and until the non-affiliated start attending en masse.

Their numbers explain how they can control the Delegate Assembly. These are the ground troops Unity uses to control the membership.

That is why I maintain that the more important elections are the chapter leaders and delegates (next in 2018) than this election because each one of these people will extract some votes out of their schools.

My guess is that the opposition needs to get people active in 500 schools before they can dent the Unity machine enough to make a difference.

I sorted them by district. High Schools are district 71-73 and 76-79, reflecting the borough high school districts.

First Name	Last Name	Division	District	School
Donnamaria	Fiscina	ES	1	Public School 015M
Dennis	Gault	ES	1	Public School 019M
Ellen	Gentilviso	K8	1	Public School 110M
Kelvin	Almonte	ES	2	Public School 002M
Jessica	Harvey	ES	2	Public School 003M
Gloria	Winograd	ES	2	Public School 006M
Haydee	Melendez	ES	4	Public School 155M
Benjy	Blatman	ES	5	Public School 125M
Beverly	Dais	ES	5	Public School 154M
Alexandra	Fischer	JH	5	Kappa Iv 302M
Conchita	Fluitt	ES	5	Public School 197M
Peggy	Girtman-Atkins	K8	5	Public School 161M
Marquis	Harrison	JH	5	Frederick Douglass Acad-M
Faiza	Khalid	ES	5	Public School 036M
Lee	Nelson	ES	6	Public School 005M
Zacharaiah	Plotkin	IS	6	Intermediate School 052M
Ruanlisa	Seignious	ES	6	Public School 132M
Marie	Baker	AD	7	Ms/Hs 368 Info & Network
Rashad	Brown	IS	7	Intermediate School 224X
Daniel	Burke	AD	7	Bx Envision Acad
Dawn	Campi	ES	7	Public School 029X
Ross	Chodan	AD	7	Urban Asmbly Math & Sci
James	Council	IS	7	Ms 296X @ I184X
Josef	Donnelly	AD	7	International Comm Hs
Sierra	Jorgensen	ES	7	Public School 157X
Evan	Lewis	AD	7	The Leadership Inst
Corinne	Barros	ES	8	Public School 062X
Jeanette	Cano-Lawson	ES	8	Public School 048X
Roxanne	Mathurin	ES	8	Public School 093X
Tracie	Abrigo	ES	9	Public School 063X
Bernadette	Alexander	ES	9	Public School 204X
Kimberly	Felder	AD	9	Bx Schl Law/Gov/Justice H
Monica	Hilton	ES	9	Public School 028X
Adrienne	Moore	ES	9	Public School 132X
Daiansa	Padin	ES	9	Public School 163X
Suri	Santos-Paulus	JH	9	Intermediate School 313X
Joann	Sims	IS	9	Intermediate School 219X
Michelle	Allen	ES	10	Public School 360X
Sandra	Hernandez	ES	10	Public School 205X
Egar	Irizarry Jr	ES	10	Public School 226X
Bonnie	Kirkwood	K8	10	Public School 279X
James	Regan	ES	10	Public School 095X
Mark	Talty	ES	10	Intermediate School 206X
Sakinah	Taylor	ES	10	Public School 033X
Lauren	Weintraub	ES	10	Public School 054X
Diane	Lucas	ES	11	Public School 103X
Christine	O'Callaghan	ES	11	Public School 106X
Timothy	Rankin	JH	11	Bx Alliance Middle School
Robert	Roache	AD	11	Bx Hs For Visual Arts
Karlene	Turner	IS	11	Intermediate School 144X
Ivan	Borras	IS	12	Entrada Acad 384X
Crystal	Coss	ES	12	Public School 061X
Erica	Gabela	JH	12	Intermediate School 190X
Donald	Saint Germain	VO	12	Bx Career & College Prep
Stevie	Burrell	AD	13	Bedford Acad Hs
Valentino	Ellis	AD	13	Benj Banneker Acad
Luther	Lohr	ES	13	Public School 287K
Pamela	Curcio	IS	14	Intermediate School 318K
Teri	Mascioli	ES	14	Public School 034K
Keith	Miller	IS	14	Intermediate School 071K
Charles	Rabbach	ES	14	Public School 297K
Andrew	Stein	ES	14	Public School 380K
Sergio	Zamora	JH	14	Jr High School 126K
Ariel	Arroyo	IS	15	Intermediate School 051K
Suzann	Bassil	ES	15	Public School 039K
Kathleen	Massar	ES	15	Public School 001K
June	Boyd	JH	16	Jr High School 057K
Ashley	Brown	AD	16	Rsrch And Srvc Hs
Latrice	Curry	ES	16	Public School 035K
Lesia	Davidson	ES	16	Public School 335K
Jean	Derico	ES	16	Public School 243K
Shalibra	Frazier	ES	16	Public School 262K
Shameeka	Hunter-Tindal	ES	16	Public School 081K
Sabina	Nwenyi	ES	16	Public School 028K Warren
Shawndell	Stewart	ES	16	Public School 005K
Wendy	Walker Wilson	ES	16	Public School 025K
Sandra	Amede	IS	17	Intermediate School 061K
Karen	Haughton	ES	17	Public School 092K
Lisa	Highland	ES	17	Public School 289K
Nomvuyo	Hyman	JH	17	Middle School 375K
Tracy	Lee	K8	17	Public School 161K
Barbara	Reill	ES	17	Public School 167K
Amy	Bernstein	ES	18	Public School 272K
Eileen	Cohen	ES	18	Public School 135K
James	Enny	IS	18	Intermediate School 068K
Gail	Ericson	ES	18	Public School 233K
Gordon	Marshall	IS	18	Intermediate School 211K
Christopher	Townsend	ES	18	Public School 268K
Errol	Wade	AD	18	Bklyn Acad Of Sci & Envir
Janet	Zysberg	K8	18	Public School 235K
Chaitram	Aklu	IS	19	Intermediate School 292K
Matthew	Dunn	JH	19	Van Siclen Community Ms	(Dunn = Dunne?)
Lesley-Anne	Jones	ES	19	Public School 158K
Denise	Salowski	ES	19	Public School 214K
Joseph	Usatch	JH	19	Jhs 311K @ Ps 190K
Lynette	Azar	K8	20	Public School 180K
Joanne	Carillo	ES	20	Public School 186K
Beatrice	Desapio	IS	20	Intermediate School 062K
Joshua	Houston	IS	20	Intermediate School 030K
Haroula	Koutsidis	PRKC	20	Pre K Ctr @ K780
Thomas	Pascarella	ES	20	Public School 048K
Joanne	Bullaro	ES	21	Public School 100K
James	Eugenio	IS	21	Intermediate School 228K
Jackie	Herman	IS	21	Is 98K Bay Acad
Georgia	Nikoloudakis	ES	21	Public School 095K
Joann	Savage	ES	21	Public School 153K
Lance	Schatzman	ES	21	Public School 329K
Steven	Blum	ES	22	Public School 269K
Fern	Carriero	K8	22	Public School 207K
Cynthia	Dinkins	ES	22	Public School 139K
Lori	Fiorentino	ES	22	Public School 236K
Marie	Kallo	IS	22	Intermediate School 234K
Martha	Murray	K8	22	Ps/Ms 109K
Sean	Blanks	IS	23	Intermediate School 392K
Elizabeth	Green	K8	23	Public School 150K
Sonja	Hill	K8	23	Public School 041K
Dawn	McDonald	ES	23	Public School 284K
Christina	Roundtree	ES	23	Christopher Ave Comm Scho
Grace	Small	ES	23	Public School 156K
Richard	Burke	ES	24	Public School 019Q
Subrina	Cek	IS	24	Intermediate School 093Q
Diane	Chiauzzi	ES	24	Public School 153Q
Patricia	Crowley	IS	24	Intermediate School 005Q
Jeanne	Gausman	ES	24	Public School 239Q
Martin	McKeown	ES	24	Public School 143Q
Tracey	Miller	IS	24	Intermediate School 125Q
Rebecca	Murphy	ES	24	Public School 091Q
Joseph	Natale	IS	24	Intermediate School 061Q
Fredda	Pichardo	ES	24	Public School 007Q
Deborah	Sherlock	ES	24	Learners And Leaders Ps 3
Susan	Stark	ES	24	Public School 088Q
Loretta	Tumbarello	ES	24	Public School 229Q
Andrew	Holz	K8	25	Public School 164Q
Lamar	Hughes	ES	25	Public School 201Q
Teresa	Fauvell	K8	26	Ps/Is 266Q
Stacy	Gangi	ES	26	Public School 188Q
Kathleen	Muzyka	ES	26	Public School 173Q
David	Waltzer	JH	26	Jr High School 158Q
Simone	Harris	K8	27	Public School 043Q
Denise	Johnson	ES	27	Public School 104Q
John	Krattinger	K8	27	Public School 042Q
Victoria	Primiano	ES	27	Public School 062Q
Sandra	Wilks-Duplan	ES	27	Public School 223Q
Renee	Williams	ES	27	Public School 273Q
Arthur	Zander	IS	27	Intermediate School 210Q
Angela	Morgan	ES	28	Public School 050Q
Richard	Niccolich	ES	28	Public School 174Q
Anthony	Valentino	ES	28	Public School 139Q
Nancy	Aromando	ES	29	Public School 118Q
James	Cutrone	K8	29	Public School 138Q	(James=Jamie?)
Melody	Davis	K8	29	Public School 268Q
Kristian	Lisowski	ES	29	Public School 033Q
Rana	Quamina	ES	29	Public School 135Q
Diane	Allison	ES	30	Public School 148Q
Jessica	Baity	ES	30	East Elmhurst Community S
Geraldine	Clark	ES	30	Public School 092Q
Adele	Goldberg	IS	30	Intermediate School 204Q
John	Gordon	IS	30	Intermediate School 145Q
Katherine	Kurjakovic	ES	30	Public School 011Q
Victoria	Mulligan	ES	30	Public School 078Q
Joann	Rodeschin	ES	30	Public School 150Q
Sandra Electra	Rodriguez	ES	30	Public School 151Q
Ashley	Rzonca	ES	30	Woodside Comm School Q361
Catherine	Sarlo	JH	30	Jr High School 010Q
Deborah	Strack-Cregan	ES	30	Public School 069Q
Noel	Warshaw	ES	30	Public School 127Q
Melody	Anastasiou	K8	31	The Si Sch Of Civic Ldrs
Kathleen	Bayer	ES	31	Public School 016R
Jessica	Jacobs	ES	31	Public School 052R
Matthew	Kirwan	ES	31	Ps 74R Future Leaders
Patricia	Mezzacappa	IS	31	Intermediate School 061R
Susan	Pulice	ES	31	Public School 056R
Veronica	Torres-Romero	ES	31	Public School 031R
Joyce	Baldino	IS	32	Intermediate School 383K
Debra	Elhadri	ES	32	Public School 075K
Helene	Loomis	ES	32	Public School 274K
Erin	Oates	IS	32	Evergreen Ms Urban Explor
Deneil	Pollock-Campbell	ES	32	Public School 299K
Richard	Skibins	ES	32	Public School 123K
Lia	Galeano	AD	71	M L King Arts & Tech Hs
Peter	O'Donnell	AD	71	M L King Hs For Law &
Glen	Pandolfino	AD	71	Hs For Environmental Stud
Tolleyne	Dickerson	AD	72	Bx Lab School
Matthew	Foglino	AD	72	Wings Acad Hs
Novelette	Foote	AD	72	Fordham Ldrshp Acad/Bus/T
Ana	Garcia	AD	72	Antonia Pantoja Prep Acad
Michael	Hayes	AD	72	Harry S Truman Hs
Alan	Richter	VO	72	Schl Tourism And Hospital
Catherine	Scott	AD	72	Bx Engineering Tech Acad
Maria	Bucca	AD	73	James Madison Hs
Deborah	Caquias	AD	73	Cultural Academy Of Arts
James	Cochran	AD	73	Hs For Youth & Community
Teresa	D'Ambrosio	AD	73	Sheepshead Bay Hs
Catena	Daskalakis	AD	73	New Utrecht Hs
Stuart	Rothstein	AD	73	Midwood Hs
Charlene	Tuff	AD	73	Edward R Murrow Hs
Michelle	Arellano	SP	75	Ps 138M @ Ps 030M
Shernice	Blackman	SP	75	Ps 177Q Robin Sue Ward Sc
Freddie	Cole	SP	75	X754 @ Jeffrey Rapport Bx
David	Doorga	SP	75	Public School 168X @ Ps 2
Lorraine	Ferrannini	SP	75	Public School 037R
Pierre	Labissiere	SP	75	Ps 53K @ Spring Creek Hs
Hans	Marryshow	SP	75	Ps 256Q @ Beach Channel H
DJ	Meehan	SP	75	Public School 224Q @ P26Q
Paula	Thomas	SP	75	Ps 4Q @ 179Q
Lisa	Viscovi	SP	75	Ps 993Q @ Ps 208Q
Alphonse	Vota	SP	75	Ps 721R @ The Hungerford
Shawn	Ramos	AD	76	New Dorp Hs
Michael	Solo	AD	76	John Dewey Hs
Kevin	Wilkinson	AD	76	Progress Hs
Adam	Bergstein	AD	77	Forest Hills Hs
Charles	Dibenedetto	AD	77	Richmond Hill Hs
Brian	Gavin	AD	77	Grover Cleveland Hs
Sharon	Kletzkin	AD	77	Math Sci Rsrch Hs
Vivian	Nobile	VO	77	Thomas A Edison Hs
Lucas	Rule	AD	77	Pathways College Prep Sch
Dino	Sferrazza	AD	77	Benjamin N Cardozo Hs
Jacqueline	Shendler	AD	77	Young Women'S Leadership
Michael	Friedman	AH	79	Pathways To Graduation Q9
Geraldo	Maldonado	AD	79	Manh Compre Night&Day
Mark	Rentflejs	AH	79	East Bklyn Community Hs
Troy	Sill	AD	79	Passages Acad

Join the Thunderclap! For #MORE2016 Get Out the Vote

What's a Thunderclap? You learn something every day. Join in. Let's see if social media outreach pumps up the vote this election cycle.

From MORE's Dan Lupkin:

Join the Thunderclap! You can think of it as an "online flash mob." Click the link to take part in a coordinated Get Out the Vote message across Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr. Fewer than 18% of working educators voted in the 2013 UFT elections; let's send a message to our colleagues and to UNITY caucus that NYC educators deserve rank-and-file leadership. It's time to demand a genuinely member-driven union!

http://thndr.me/KT9C78

 

 

Some Predictions as UFT Election Ballots in the Mail: 63 Thousand Retirees Can Vote - Division Totals Below

UFT members should start receiving their ballots today, tomorrow and Monday. (If you don't get it by Tuesday May 11 contact the AAA to get another one.) Vote totals for MORE/NA are very dependent on how hard people work in their schools to get the vote out. In the past I think the totals were suppressed because people didn't do enough.

My long national nightmare ends on May 26 when I observe the vote count before heading downtown for the MORE end of election party. I only have a thousand more leaflets to get out.

Unless there are some very big surprises in the outcomes that would offer hope for the future, I will consider myself on F-U time - my sense of obligation to do UFT work and try to build an opposition crap ends. I have no intention to be involved in another election. I may continue to do stuff but guilt will no longer be a driving force because if MORE/NA can't make even a bit of a dent this time then what is the point for someone like me to stay deeply involved? There will still be an opposition and I intend to report more openly on goings on in MORE and the rest of the opposition. In other words, be more of reporter than an organizer. And I have a lot to report, including doing a detailed tell-all history of MORE.

Retirees Largest Block in UFT
Check out the numbers of ballots sent out. Aside from the outcomes, we will be watching how many were returned in each division. Note that the biggest batch of ballots sent out were the 62,991 to retirees and about 30-33% generally return their ballots, with roughly 80-85% going to Unity. Assume 23000 return this time and retiree preferences stay the same, the election starts with Unity having almost 20,000 votes and MORE/NA with about 3,000 based on past numbers.

If MORE/NA can get over 20% of the retiree vote that would be a breakthrough.

Let's assume a bump for MORE/NA due to the recent retirees not being all that happy.

Give Unity - 17-8,000, MORE/NA - 4-5000.  Can MORE/NA make up a 12- 14,000 initial vote gap by outpolling Unity in the other divisions? Before I address that issue here is some relevant info on the retiree vote.

Up to 23,000 of these retiree votes count for a full vote. If the number or returns goes above that then they are prorated. So theoretically if 46,000 retirees vote each counts as a .5 vote. Unity Caucus has adjusted the number allowed up from 15000 to 18000 to 23000 as more retirees vote. Only one time did the actual vote totals go about the limit.

If retirees break much above the 23,000 number this year will Unity try to raise the number again? I am not sure they will raise the limit again. I was an observer at the 2013 count and when we were told that 52% of the returns were retirees some of the union leaders there look extremely uncomfortable with that number. If we get more of a turnout from the working divisions and MORE/NA make serious gains Unity will probably raise the retiree cap to 25000 for next time.

127,000 working UFT members, 66,000 teachers to vote. Can MORE/NA make up a 14,000 gap?

Of course what Unity does in the future depends on the outcomes in the 3 key divisions: elementary, middle school and high school which is where the 66,000 teacher votes reside. (Below I'll address the large block of the over 46,000 non-teaching functionals).

One of the reasons I don't focus on challenging the retiree vote is that the opposition must show it can win the 3 divisional teacher vote first. Until that time there is no point in wasting energy on that battle. If the day comes where MORE wins the majority of teacher votes then a court case becomes feasible on the retiree vote.

If the day comes that the opposition wins these 23 executive board seats it will be a new ball game.

What percentage of teachers will vote? 

Look at how many ballots were sent out yesterday:

·        The total number of ballots that were printed and mailed is 189, 469

o   Elementary: 35, 606

o   JHS: 11,197

o   HS (Academic/CTE): 19,539

o   Functional Chapters: 46, 731

o   Retiree: 62,991

The above numbers are roughly in line with the 2013 numbers except for a 5000 bump in retiree votes.

In the 2013 election about 9000 elementary, 1800 middle  and 3500 high school teachers voted.

These are the crucial areas of concern because retirees don't vote in these divisions, thus giving the opposition a fighting chance. Unless MORE/NA can make a dent in all these divisions little will change in the UFT.

High Schools
Expect the high schools to roughly break 50-50 as they have done over the past 25 years. In 2013 MORE and New Action together got about 2000 votes while Unity got around 1600 but the NA votes went to Unity. If nothing changes it would be a slam dunk for MORE/NA. If Unity numbers go up (though why anyone in high school would vote for Unity) say 4000 and MORE/NA stay the same as last time it is a horse race. I would hope MORE/NA can do better than last time and force Unity to really hustle for those 7 high school seats. If MORE/NA managed 60% that would be a wowzer. Sometimes I have the feeling that Unity is ambivalent about having 100% of the exec bd if we lose the high schools, thus pulling away their fiction of bi-partisanship, one of the benefits of New Action and Unity breaking. But knowing Unity they want the whole enchilada. The only negative if MORE/NA wins the high schools is that I have to treat Schirtzer to a Peter Lugar steak.

Middle schools
The middle schools are interesting given the low vote totals in the past -- out of 12,000 ballots sent out in 2013 Unity only got about 1100 votes. MORE and New Action combined got less than 700 together. How much fun would it be if MORE/NA was competitive in the middle schools? It would take only a flip of a few hundred votes.


Elementary schools
Elementary schools are worth watching to see if Unity totals drop and MORE/NA go up. Unity totals dropped seriously from 2010 to 2013 but MORE/NA were roughly stable.

The elementary outcome will be a key indicator of an anti-Unity movement in the union. If MORE/NA break the 35% barrier I consider that movement. Anything approaching 40% would create panic in Unity.

Functional chapters
They are all lumped together which I believe is undemocratic. Note the large number of non-teacher functional ballots - almost 47,000. Pro Unity totals always come in higher in the functionals. My guess is that Unity maintains very tight control of the individual chapters in the functionals - especially the paras which is the biggest block.
Unity gets higher numbers than in the school divisions even if so many functionals are getting screwed.

Some people knock the opposition for focusing on teachers at this point. I believe this is due to the inability to get much traction in the functionals without some strong leadership coming out of those divisions to work with the opposition. Thus a secretary of para who is ready to help organize in their chapter is a necessary antecedent for making a dent there. What I find is that there are complaints about Unity but an expectation that MORE/NA teachers will do that organizing, which to me is not organic - believe me over my 40 years I've been there, done that and it doesn't get very far.

If you don't get your ballot

·        500 extra ballots were printed for each division used for people who did not receive a ballot and call AAA to request one.

·        AAA is responsible for securing the ballots from the post office on a daily basis and safely storing them until the morning of May 26^th.

·        Ballots are opened on the day of the count.

No matter what the outcome join us at the MORE party at the Dark Horse on May 26 to celebrate the hard work people have been doing.

UFT Election Respite: Volunteering at Brooklyn Botanic Garden Plant Sale

This is the time of the year when gardening comes to the fore. For the past 30 years I have been volunteering at the Botanic Garden plant sale which always starts around the first Wednesday of May - preceding Mothers Day.

During all this time Lois Carswell ran the event with an iron hand - she was like a general -- the complexities of doing this massive event in the cherry blossom area was like a military operation requiring hundreds of volunteers and much of the Garden staff. After her death last year some people have stepped up to fill her shoes and this is the 2nd year they have managed to pull it off even though they cut one day off because it is just too much for people who have other careers. I worked there on Tuesday and yesterday setting up for the 4:30 opening which ran till 8 - but by 7:30 I was too chilled to stay.

But today it runs from 9 AM - 8 PM and it will be drizzling all day and I am taking changes of clothing. And my checkbook. Every year I end up spending hundreds of dollars for my garden - there are just so many interesting things being offered. Since the Sandy hurricane I have had to rebuild my garden and have come up with a unique idea -- my version of the high line - which I am dubbing the Low Line - or Norms Line. I'm heading over soon to spend the day and bring home another batch of plants.

If you happen to come by look for me in perennials which I prefer over working inside the tent with the annuals and house plants.

I spent $250 yesterday as I filled an entire wagon. I consider this twisted stem willow the star of the show -- there were only 2 of them and I managed to get one.  Now I have to plant it - on my front "lawn" which as you can see no longer exists.

And here are the other 7 plants I bought yesterday.

Below is a beach plum I bought last year just as it was blooming. What a thrill to see this at the entrance to my house. I got the only one they had last year. This year they have another one and I was contemplating getting it but (luckily) someone grabbed it and made my decision for me. I learned that it bears edible plums so here's hoping for a crop this year.

As a teacher Brooklyn Botanic Gardens was one of my favorite trips to take my class to. I used to take them for a series of 3 or 4 week classes there - they would plant something the first week and take the plant home on the 4th week.

My love of plants and gardening came from Mrs. Feinstein my 5th grade teacher who had plants all over the room and did the lima bean growing project with us where we started with a bean in a milk carton and watched it spout and grow into a full size plant. I did that same project with my class every year.

One of the complications was that they did not allow eating lunch in the Gardens so you had to get an appointment and use their lunch room. So instead I would take them across the street to Prospect Park to eat. Of course, good weather was essential.

In the years before I retired I also volunteered during the summers to work with a gardener and that was a great experience - he was a right wing conservative and we had such a blast arguing politics. I had hoped to commit to a regular volunteering gig at the garden but my other activities and my focus on my own garden has made that difficult. There is no better place to escape from the world than Brooklyn Botanic Gardens, one of the great oases in the midst of a major city.

Maybe this year if I can manage to lower my activity in the UFT political scene -if you see my at a Delegate Assembly next year ask me why I'm not at the Gardens.

POTUS16: Indiana a win-win for Trump, a lose-lose for Hillary - Will Dem Party Arrogance of Assumptions Be Wiped Off their faces?

Roseanne McCosh comments: Dems know it'll always be a nose hold or a compromise that results in a vote for a democrat....but what if they get it wrong this time? What if we hold our nose and vote for Trump? .... By 2016 my hatred for the Democratic Party (Obama and his RTT, Cuomo! and Hillary), has deep roots and I will now vote republican regardless of who it is until the democrats earn my vote back.... Hillary is a pro war corporate whore. And if that's the best the dems can present to me on election day then I'm going republican. At least they tell me upfront that they're going to f%#k me and 99% of the things I care about. Hilary, like Obama, is the handsome charming guy who promises you wine and roses and then slips you a roofie.... For the first time since I naively voted for Ronald Reagan at the age of 19 in 1984, I will be voting for the republican presidential candidate. After 1984 I voted democrat until I voted Green Party in 2012..... 

Trump won and it is pretty much all over for the Republican nomination while Hillary lost and will have to deal with Bernie till the bitter end. Who woulda predicted this even a few weeks ago?

How much trouble are Hillary and the Democrats in? Can Trump actually win? Roseanne commented on my post: POTUS16: On Elections and Political Parties - Part 1


Hillary lost Indiana to Bernie and the slow drip goes on. How many Bernie supporters will vote Trump or not vote at all or go Green?
I picked up my friend this morning coming off the red-eye after 4 months in California, a former DOE guy, and he said he just won't vote of write someone in.

I think teachers - especially those who have experienced ed deform first hand at the hands of the Dems - are very risky - and Randi's umbilical connection to the Dems and Hillary - and also the way the AFT/UFT/NYSUT endorsed her - will see some chickens come home to roost no matter how much they pull the scared of Trump card.  
 
I have been hearing similar thoughts from some people - maybe not enough to influence the election in crucial states. I've written about my surprise when I was at the NPE on some Bernie supporters saying they will not vote for Hillary and rather than not voting or going 3rd party they will vote for Trump partly in spite but also hoping for that things will go so far downhill under him we will see a Bernie type candidate in 2020 who can make real changes.

On the other hand, just as many Republicans will not vote for Trump - especially the hawks who see Hillary as a better choice. Plus many women and others. So despite desertions from the left Trump will face more from the right. The establishment Republicans may well feel more comfortable with Hillary.

And how about that Hillary stuff with the coal miner where she had to walk back from talking about being proud to take their jobs with no plan for supporting them - pretty much the entire free trade thingy where there was no plan for retraining - in the neo-liberal world it is sink or swim.

Here are some interesting articles on where Hillary really stands.

Anti-Capitalist Meetup: How Neoliberal is Hillary Clinton?
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2015/7/19/1403488/-Anti-Capitalist-Meetup-How-Neoliberal-is-Hillary-Clinton

Salon:
Saturday, Dec 26, 2015 09:30 AM EST

Is Hillary Clinton a neoconservative hawk? What Iraq and Libya decisions tell us about her foreign policy

Hillary got Iraq vote wrong, and Libya and Syria too. If she were setting the policies, what would they look like?

Paul Rosenberg  

$1.5 Milion Common Core PD for UFT as Mulgrew Jumps on Gravy Train Plus DOE Contract With Joel Kein/Murdoch's Failed Amplify

Mulgrew wanted to punch you in the face if you took his common core - less than 2 years ago. Then as the worm turned the Unity Caucus/UFT leadership started talking trash about the common core. But that doesn't stop them from jumping on the gravy train for the teacher center which is a patronage mill for Unity to the tune of $1.5 million from state ed dept.

Another bribe to the UFT to keep them on board ed deform policies?

Think about this when your UFT election ballot arrives this weekend and not only VOTE MORE but also make sure the people in your school consider doing the same. Let's turn this corrupt union upside down.

Reports of a big retroactive UFT contract for Common Core PD:




Retroactive UFT contract for $ 1.5M supposedly named in state grant as vendor – also got a federal SIG grant which supposedly explains the delay in asking for the contract’s approval.

Check out what it’s being spent on:

pp. 94-95

http://schools.nyc.gov/NR/rdonlyres/E2692E42-609E-4231-A149-EE47FA325AC0/196163/May182016RAsCompro.pdf





And why not give life to Joel Klein's Rosemary's Baby, Amplify -  see new Amplify contract  p. 89 $650K per year for seven years at $4.6 M

http://schools.nyc.gov/NR/rdonlyres/E2692E42-609E-4231-A149-EE47FA325AC0/196163/May182016RAsCompro.pdf
"Amplify advised that Mr. Klein is no longer an employee, is not one of the investors, nor does he service on its Board, however, he may serve as an advisory." Translation: Uncle Joel will still be on the DOE dole.

POTUS16: Presidential Election: Thinking About Post Election Populist Movements on the Left (and Right)

Is there a post election future of the Sanders movement?
(It Won't Be Over Even if Hillary is Nominee: Sand...)
 
Is there a post election future for Trump supporters, especially if he loses to Hillary? Tea Party morphing into populists? Probably not.

Are there any areas of unity between Bernie and Trump people? Trump people are wooing and as I pointed out recently POTUS16: On Elections and Political Parties - Part... some Bernie supporters among MORE readers and people I met at NPE - these are not right wingers -  will not vote for Hillary but Trunp - others will go 3rd party.

Look at this comment on that post: If you are "meeting too many people" who will vote for Trump, I think you should take stock of the kind of places you are frequenting - clearly someone who would shun any contact with a Trump supporter. I find that amusing but don't have time go get into the "who you hang out with" stuff - I know lots of people on the left who live in a bubble of their own.

What about the role our union on the city, state and national level play in the Democratic party?

Can the Democratic Party be moved left generally?

Can the Democratic Party be moved away from ed deform?

Many people on the left have given up on the Democratic Party - don't read any further here until you read: New Politics, The Sanders Campaign and the Left which points out the bankruptcy of the party and how there is no hope without some kind of 3rd party - think of the disappearance of the Whigs in the 1850s and the foundation of the Republican Party. Also in England how parties have come and gone.

Will your vote have an impact in UFT elections? Let's leave that for another time other than to say if you vote for Unity it won't.

I have few answers to these questions but intend to explore some of them over the next few months. While I have this stuff on my mind I will put a bunch of stuff up today before it all disappears in a vapor.

Let's face it. I am not happy with either Clinton, Obama, Cuomo, De Blasio and some of the frustration actually has driven me more to the right of the left where I used to be. My libertarian tendencies cannot be suppressed. I believe Hillary will not be a good president - for a lot of reasons. As one who had the Nixon threat drummed into me since 1960 I find it amusing to see people pining for Hillary who is to the right of Nixon.

Some of my blogging colleagues say hold your noses and vote for Hillary to keep Trump away.

Hillary is a neocon as the April 24 NY Times mag pointed out plus others: How Hillary Clinton Became a Hawk - The New York ... see below for a list of Hillary as neocon articles.

The anti-capitalist left often talks about Hillary's neo-liberalism - which is not the same as neo-con: Anti-Capitalist Meetup: How Neoliberal is Hillary Clinton?

I put up a post the other day from Counterpunch that called for Bernie to run as 3rd party on the Green ticket. I think that is pretty impossible to imagine but did get a hissy fit comment from someone who is clearly a Hillary supporter:

HarringtonianMonday, May 2, 2016 at 2:03:00 PM EDT

This is what the paranoid style of politics ('progressive' edition) looks like. In the very unlikely event this advice were to be actually followed, Bernie would end up as the pathetic Henry Wallace of his generation or worse, Ralph Nader on steroids. Either way it would stab the 'political revolution' in the heart. OTOH, it would be so satisfying to the Dilettante Left!

Ah yes, the Dilettante left coming from a Dilettante "hold your nose" Hillary supporter. When you hold your nose and vote for her better get a clothespin.

Stab the political revolution in the heart? Like voting for Hillary is not stabbing the political revolution in the heart? Like is there any chance the Democratic Party will ever become progressive? You have to look far and wide to find a New Deal Democrat and look at education alone - public ed knifed in the back time and again and Hillary will do the same though she may be slicker than Obama in fooling people and she will have Randi/Mulgrew there to run interference for her.

When asked if I am a socialist - in the anti-capitalist vein - I cannot say I am even though many of my political associates would classify themselves as such. I put myself in the left-wing social democrat category which is where Bernie Sanders seems to come from. Of course to the far left and even some of the near left anti-capitalists, an SD is anathema since SDs accept capitalism but want it highly regulated and taxed.

Let's face it. Either Hillary or Trump will be the next president. I am not as hysterical about the outcome if it is Trump as so many others. Is Trump dangerous? They all are dangerous. If looking for a sliver - you won't have to hear "common core" shoved down your throat.

My thinking is driven by where I feel I'm at politically at this point. A registered Democrat, I have never believed very much in the party and have voted 3rd party about 50% of the time (Clinton, Obama first terms, not the 2nd, Nader, etc.). Like so many others I feel the 2-party system has left me with few choices and I believe it is time for a 3rd and maybe 4th viable party or at the very least a realignment. The Bernie and Trump campaigns actually offer post-election opportunities, especially if Hillary wins.

Afterburn: Hillary as a neocon
Hillary is a neocon as the April 24 NY Times mag pointed out plus others: How Hillary Clinton Became a Hawk - The New York ...

Others are putting that out there too:

1. Are Neocons Getting Ready to Ally With Hillary ...

   www.nytimes.com/2014/07/06/opinion/sunday/are-neocons...

   Jul 04, 2014 · Neocons like the historian Robert Kagan may be connecting with Hillary Clinton to try to regain influence in foreign policy. Credit Left, Stephanie ...

2. Is Hillary Clinton a Neocon-Lite? – Consortiumnews

   consortiumnews.com/2015/04/23/is-hillary-clinton...

   ... including editorial writers at the New York Times who mocked Brazil and ... Hillary Clinton is a shill for Wall Street ... Is Hillary Clinton a Neocon ...

3. Hillary Clinton Seeks Neocon Shelter –...

   consortiumnews.com/2016/01/22/hillary-clinton...

   ... Hillary Clinton is hoping that ... neocon superstar Robert Kagan told The New York Times in 2014 that ... 48 comments for “ Hillary Clinton Seeks Neocon ...

4. Is Hillary Clinton a Neocon? | Cato Institute

   www.cato.org/.../commentary/is-hillary-clinton-neocon

   Senator Hillary Clinton, MSNBC, ... Is Hillary Clinton a Neocon? By Edward H. Crane. ... the New York Times columnist. Mr.

5. Daily Kickoff: Hillary Clinton the Neocon? | Dayan...

   www.jewishjournal.com/jewish_insider/item/daily_kickoff...

   Daily Kickoff: Hillary Clinton the Neocon? ... [Eater; NYTimes] BIRTHDAYS: ... Get the Jewish Journal in your inbox.

6. When Hillary Clinton Out-Neoconned a Neocon - FPIF

   fpif.org/hillary-clinton-neoconned-neocon

   When Hillary Clinton Out-Neoconned a Neocon. ... Hillary Clinton was the recipient of much criticism for her ... (as Frank Rich wrote in the New York Times in 2002 ...

#MORE2016 UFT Election Video: Dan Lupkin and Megan Moskop

I just love these videos showcasing the active members of MORE. Note that these are people on the front end of their careers with a long way to go. As someone who hasn't seen this age group (20s to 40ish) active in the opposition to Unity since the 70s I find that invigorating. Of course we also always track the long-time staying power of people who if they don't see some movement in policy within the UFT can get discouraged or just lose interest. The future of the opposition will not be told when this election ends but over the next year or two when there is no election activity. I dropped in to last night's MORE steering committee meeting and saw signs of post-election planning for the summer series. After the election I'm going to delve into some history and will explore the group dynamics both positive and negative.

#MORE2016 UFT Election Video: Ashraya Gupta

#MORE2016 UFT Election Video: Marcus McArthur on Why Vote MORE?

Marcus McArthur is running for one of the 7 seats on the high school executive board, seats that are winnable if high school teachers check off the MORE/New Action box on the slate. Watch this video and imagine Marcus and the rest of the high school slate Arthur Goldstein, Ashraya Gupta, Mike Schirtzer, David Garcia-Rosen, Jonathan Halabi, and Kuljit Arhuwalia speaking up for all teachers.

Charter Scam: KIPP and Department of Education Conspire to Hide Graduation Data from Public While Seeking Millions in Taxpayer Money

Real public schools would never be allowed to claim that high school graduation rates or college matriculation rates are "proprietary" or "privileged" or "confidential."

Why does the Education Department's Charter School Program "Office of Innovation and Improvement" defer to KIPP's demand to keep that information secret from the public?

How public are KIPP public schools?
Not as public as real or traditional public schools.
New documents discovered on the U.S. Department of Education's website reveal that KIPP has claimed that information about its revenues and other significant matters is "proprietary" and should be redacted from materials it provides to that agency to justify the expenditure of federal tax dollars, before its application is made publicly available.
So what does a so-called public school like KIPP want to keep the public from knowing?

professor Gary Miron and his colleagues Jessica Urschel and Nicholas Saxton, found that "KIPP charter middle schools enroll a significantly higher proportion of African-American students than the local school districts they draw from but 40 percent of the black males they enroll leave between grades 6 and 8," as reported by Mary Ann Zehr in Ed Week....

Just a few tidbits from this must read from CMD on charter scam:
Center for Media and Democracy exposes KIPP's Efforts to Keep the Public in the Dark while Seeking Millions in Taxpayer Subsidies - 

See more at: http://www.prwatch.org/news/2016/04/13096/exposed-cmd-kipps-efforts-keep-public-dark-while-seeking-millions-taxpayer#sthash.6gTURnoO.dpuf

The Push to Make Sanders the Green Party’s Candidate

Bernie Sanders, to the consternation of critics in the Democratic Party, pundits in the corporate media, and purists on the hard left, has accomplished an amazing thing. Up against Hillary Clinton, surely the biggest, best-funded corporate-backed candidate the Democratic leadership has run since Walter Mondale lost to Ronald Reagan in 1984 over three decades ago, the once obscure independent Vermont senator has battled Clinton to almost a draw, down by only some 319 delegates with nearly 900 to go (not counting the corrupt “super delegates” chosen for their fealty to party leaders, not by primary or caucus voting.)
By doing this well, as a proudly declared “democratic socialist” who on the stump has been denouncing the corruption of both the US political and economic systems, and as a candidate who has refused to take corporate money or money from big, powerful donors, instead successfully funding his campaign with only small two and three-digit donations from his supporters, Sanders has exposed not just his opponent, Hillary Clinton, but the entire Democratic Party leadership and most of its elected officials as nothing but hired corporate tools posing as progressive advocates of the people.
But now Sanders faces a truly momentous choice. Defeated by the combined assault of a pro-corporate mass media and by the machinations of the Democratic Party leadership — machinations both long-established with the intent of defeating upstarts and outsiders, like front-loading conservative southern states in the primary schedule, and current, like scheduling only a few early candidate debates and then slotting them at times (like opposite the Super Bowl) when few would be watching them — Sanders knows that barring some major surprise like a federal indictment of Clinton, a market collapse, or perhaps a leak of the transcripts of Clinton’s highly-paid but still secret speeches to some of the nation’s biggest banks, he is not going to win the Democratic nomination.
So does he, after spending months hammering home the reality that Clinton is the bought-and-paid candidate of the the banks, the arms industry, the oil industry and the medical-industrial complex, and after enduring endless lies about his own record spouted by Clinton and her surrogates, go ahead and endorse her as the party’s standard bearer for the general election? Does he walk away and return quietly to Vermont? Or does he instead continue to fight for his “political revolution” by another route?
The first and even the second option would mean the demise of his so-called “political revolution.”

More at:
http://www.counterpunch.org/2016/04/29/the-push-to-make-sanders-the-green-partys-candidate/

WTF is Wrong with Americans

Sources in the Poster Student loan debt growth, take your pick of sources. Here's one For-profit school deregulation. http://huff.to/for-profit-dereg Military expenditures, top 15 countures. http://bit.ly/SIPRI-yearbook-2011 This comic adapts some text from Letter of Support for Quebec Students from Nordic Students
Follow Occupy* Posters Tumblr Blog - the main site where all Occupy* Posters stuff gets released. The 20+ most viral works by Occupy* Posters - You may have already seen this stuff making the rounds, or held high on a street near you. Check 'em out! On Facebook On Twitter On Pinterest Occupy* Posters' coolest stuff on shirts UPDATE: No one has noticed the parody proprietary "school" in this comic, Shareholder's University, or they have but have just not mentioned it in the comments. Of course, no such entity exists by name. However, all publicly-traded "schools" are exactly that: by law, they exist first to benefit shareholders, not students.   

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2012/06/26/1103368/-The-One-Comic-That-Explains-Just-How-Screwed-America-Is?detail=emailclassic&link_id=5&can_id=72b9504de33edbcca120fc745918b180&source=email-someone-finally-polled-the-1-and-its-not-pretty&email_referrer=someone-finally-polled-the-1-and-its-not-pretty&email_subject=someone-finally-polled-the-1-and-its-not-pretty

Mulgrew Must Step Down | Teacher Letter in Queens Tribune

Teacher Stephany Verra puts forth a pretty good summary of the Unity Caucus leadership. But even if Mulgrew took her advice Unity Caucus would just put a clone in his place to do the same things. It is time to rally people to break the Unity 60 year power grip on our local, state and national union. Every vote going to MORE/New Action is another nail in their coffin even if we don't win the entire enchilada this time. Break their control over the schools through their district rep management structure. I don't know Stephany Verra but she gets it -- now if she has to get others to vote for MORE/New Action.

Are education departments in local universities virtually empty? My yoga teacher today told me she has one more year to go at Brooklyn College. I have to check with her. If there were a teacher shortage they might actually have to end the ATR crisis.

To The Editor:
Since Former Mayor Mike Bloomberg took office in 2002 and assumed control of New York City schools, the leadership in the IFT has been complicit in the privatization of public school scheme, supportive of incessant testing, allowing UFT members to become victims of age discrimination and ultimately is clearly part of the scheme to deprofessionalize the teaching profession.
UFT President Michael Mulgrew, a huge supporter of the highly unpopular Common Core standard and data-driven teaching and learning, has been largely unresponsive to members’ concerns and in many cases pleas for help. What kind of labor leader would ignore his or her numbers? Members pay a tremendous amount in dues every year.

What have they gotten in return? Teachers have been abused, harassed, brought up on false charges and even fired. Teachers in many schools continue to work in hostile environments – with administrators who are incompetent, inexperienced and/or abusive. They continue to harass teachers because they know very well that the UFT will do nothing about it.

The City is currently in the process of settling lawsuits against them brought on by teachers through private attorneys for this abuse and harassment. Is this how taxpayers’ funds for public schools are being wasted? Does the Department of Education really need hundreds of lawyers currently employed by the New York City Department of Education?

Despite what Mulgrew says publicly, the UFT leadership has taken NO steps to improve the working conditions of teachers. None. The education departments in local universities are virtually empty. We are at a precipice of a teacher shortage in New York City. The biggest losers of a teacher shortage will be the students.

Mulgrew must accept the blame for the teacher shortage, miserable working environment in many schools and his reluctance to call for the removal of hundreds of  horrible school administrators still in our schools.

Stephany Verra,
Little Neck

http://queenstribune.com/mulgrew-must-step-down/

#MORE2016 UFT Election Video: Elementary VP Candidate Lauren Cohen on Why Vote MORE/New Action

#MORE2016 UFT Election Video: Michelle Baptiste on Why Vote MORE/New Action

https://youtu.be/jwrrDCb7JB8

POTUS16: New Politics - The Sanders Campaign and the Left - Part 2

Senator Bernie Sanders’ run for the Democratic Party nomination for president has certainly energized thousands. It has also rekindled an old debate on the American left that revolves around the question: Should the left join, endorse, support, or work for campaigns in the Democratic Party?... New Politics, The Sanders Campaign and the Left

This is part 2 of my series on POTUS16. (Part 1: POTUS16: On Elections and Political Parties - Part 1).

Can the Democratic Party be taken over by progressive forces or is there a need for a new party? You might term this "The Case Against Bernie."

Sanders remains proud of his opposition to the Patriot Act—still supported by Clinton—which authorized mass surveillance by the National Security Agency. So why didn’t he point out the hypocrisy of a Cabinet member not trusting the government with her personal emails but feeling perfectly fine about the most intimate private data of the rest of us being subject to a vast and secret system of government spying?²³

This piece written in October 2015 which is pretty predictive of what has happened to Bernie from New Politics, The Sanders Campaign and the Left. There is so much meat in this piece which delves into history of Bernie like movements in the Democratic Party and how they end up strengthening the 2 party system.

Most people see the left as monolithic. It is far from that and I will be exploring some of the forces on the left when I have time after the UFT elections. Some people suggested MORE endorse Bernie to win over the Bernie people in the elections. Reading this article might provide some insights as to pushback from some of the left to out and out Bernie support.

NOTE: Publishing this does not mean I agree with all aspects but a lot of it does make sense. I do not classify myself as an anti-capitalist socialist but as a left wing social democrat who wants strict controls on capitalism - which is where I think Bernie comes from. This piece comes from the anti-capitalist left. I've highlighted some of the points that strike me. Of interest to us is the relationship of labor unions to the Democratic party - especially the way Randi has embedded our union in the party.

The article does not seem to take into account the Bernie fundraising which has gone beyond Hillary's. Is there a future way forward around Citizen's United? Or is it more likely to dissapate as Hillary throws him a few bones for the platform until he fades into the night?

The Sanders Campaign and the Left
http://newpol.org/print/content/sanders-campaign-and-left

Winter 2016

Vol:XV-4

Whole #: 60

POTUS16: On Elections and Political Parties - Part 1

I want to do a series of posts exploring where we might be going with the Bernie and Trump movements vis a vis the current 2 party Republican and Democratic Parties which have both drifted way right of where they were - like Hillary and Obama are to the right of Nixon.

The so-called "left" actually has a lot of wings - and at times I feel I have touched base with all of them - just within MORE I've seen a wide range of the left - or to use a broader more inclusive term - "progressives." I think a dividing line is whether one is anti-capitalist or reform capitalism drastically left - the latter is where Bernie Sanders seems to be coming from. The social democrats which is where I put myself.

The idea of a viable party of the left with deep roots might have some legs given the post-election landscape. I posted about this sort of Occupy/Bernie follow-up in Chicago: It Won't Be Over Even if Hillary is Nominee.

It is one thing to become a sort of lobby group. Some people might imagine using the super fund raising ability of Bernie people to fuel such left wing lobby group, which I think is a dead end.

What is needed is a political party of sorts though I can't imagine what that might look like at this point.

Meanwhile there is a war of sorts between our allies over whether to vote for Hillary or not, with even some of our allies seeing Trump as a better alternative to her - especially from teachers outraged by the neo-liberal assault on education and the role Randi and Hillary have played in it - check some of the comments on this blog and I even met at least a few people at the NPE of all places who said they would vote Trump over Hillary. Their thinking was that Hillary will be more of the same while a Trump victory would discredit the neo-liberal, war hawk wing of the Democratic Party - and Randi too and he would be so outrageous that would either move the Democrats to the left or lead to a split in the party and maybe even a split in the Republican Party too.

I am meeting too many people who say Bernie is their first choice and Trump their 2nd. Something is resonating.

I will explore the possibilities based on either outcome in follow-ups.

There are 3 options out there for Bernie people.
Vote for Hillary
Vote 3rd Party
and I know this will drive people crazy - vote for Trump -

Arthur Goldstein at NYC Educator will not vote for Hillary or Trump: Hillary's Haters
Mr. Talk returns to blogging with his reasons why we must vote for Hillary:

Accountable Talk

As Bernie's Ship Sinks, Please Don't Pull the Rest of Us Down With You

Mr. Talk argues against Arthur's 3rd party vote even in Blue states because he feels Hillary need to be elected with a mandate. Like Obama in 2012? That did a lot of good. I think given Hillary's neo-liberalism a mandate for her would justify those policies and any educator who has seen the assault of  neo-liberalism must take that into account. If you have doubts about Hillary my follow-ups will include proof that Hillary in substance is a middle of the road Republican.