Saturday, July 10, 2010

Updated Again: AFT Update - and Gates as the Most Dangerous Man in America

Update 2: July 11, 1am PST

The morning session is over and we are pre-Gates, but this came in from Leonie Haimson:

Hope its not too late to create a buzz at Seattle…please share!

The most dangerous man in America is taking the stage at the AFT conference in Seattle today:

Watch out, America! You have nothing to lose but your public school system, at the hands of the richest man in the country who, like a spoiled child carelessly playing with toys, breaks one after another.

check it out at

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/leonie-haimson/the-most-dangerous-man-in_b_641832.htm

Key debates on educational issues
[I have video of it all so won't go into tremendous detail.]

The most controversial issues on education were up for debate this morning. Reso # 5 on teacher evaluation was supposed to be the most contentious. Randi/Unity prepared carefully. A few weeks ago the Unity delegation met in NY and were told this was the crucial reso and were prepared to manipulate in committee and at the floor debate.

Chicago vs NYC was a key background. Chicago/CORE people were a little taken aback at some of the tactics used at the committee meetings on Thursday. At the main sessions one CORE/CTU teacher after another were the key people standing up to Unity/Progressive Caucus, telling of the experience of being in the belly of the Duncan/Daly beast.

Today on Reso 5 the mics were packed with Progressive Caucus people until Randi pulled the democracy issue and "allowed" 2 people - CTUers it turned out - to speak against some of the language that they said opened up teachers to attacks. But then the question was called as we always see in NYC.

Chicago and NYC cooperate
On the closing schools reso we saw a different scenario. A UFTer/Unity got up to amend the reso and everything she said was on the mark. The next speaker was from Chicago/CORE - local 1 - and thanked local 2 for working with them to strengthen the reso. Both speeches were very powerful.

I spoke to CORE people after and apparently there were some intense negotiations between the two big powerhouse locals to find some common ground. And they did.

What is playing out here is a baptism of the Chicago group just a few days after taking power in the union. I have been very impressed with the number of quality people. One after another you speak to are articulate and educated on so many issues. CORE clearly has done a great job of educating, organizing and mobilizing. In two years at Detroit they will be prepared.

But that won't stop Randi from trying to coopt them, something she is so good at doing.

To be continued

------
Everyone wants part of the GEM banner - well, not everyone

Speaking of co-opting. New Action's Jonathan Halabi is here. Now don't get into a snit. New Action did not get delegate positions. He is here as college prof delegate - PSC. As some of you know he is not my favorite person for his constant ICE bashing - he was even overheard doing it in a bar the other night. You know, "the ICE opposes everything mantra" - like mayoral control, merit pay, measuring teachers by data - stuff like that. Stuff that the UFT has supported.

When there was discussion about the Gates protest today and people talked about holding up the GEM banner, there are reports Halabi balked, saying GEM was sectarian or something like that. Ridiculous. Though GEM has many ICE people in it, it has attracted people from every active group in the UFT. Not New Action of course. GEM has not been active within the UFT very much and is not a caucus, one of the reasons so many ICE people who feel there is a need for a broader movement than just a caucus have jumped on board. New Action on the other hand sticks to the narrowest of issues and does little more than function as a completely owned subsidiary of Unity.

In defense of ICE/GEM
Pretty ironic that Lisa North and Gloria Brandman, two key ICE people have been amongst the leaders of the the AFT P&J committee which Halabi has been hanging around. And they have been on the UFT Peace and Justice Committee. And the UFTers to stop the war.

Other ICEer/GEMers: Fiorillo is one of most respected voices out there. As is John Lawhead. Julie Woodward has been relentless in holding the UFT's feet to the fire. Arthur Goldstein is chapter leader of the second largest school in the city and is one of the leading voices in defense of teachers with his columns at Gotham Schools. Eterno and Kaufman have been enormously respected for their strength and knowledge of the contract. And John Elfrank chapter leader of Murray Bergtraum. And the retirees: Ellen Fox, Loretta and Gene Prisco, Vera Pavone who co-wrote the review of the Kahlenberg book with me - and she did most of the work. It's late. I'm sure I'm forgetting people. Jeez! The nerve to disparage the work of these people.

How else have we been able to build alliances with just about every group in the city - teachers and community activists? From NYCORE to Teachers Unite to TJC. And parent groups around the city. People I meet here from all over the nation know our work and want to stay in touch. Ed Notes received over 2000 hits in the last 3 days alone.

We have links nationwide. Chicago CORE are allies and we've been spending time with them. Karen Lewis know our work. And the Washington DC crew with Candi Peterson and Nathan Saunders who are here. Detroit called us when they were taking action. LA people are in touch. We linked to a group in Philly on this trip. Now, quick - name New Action activists who have done anything close to this work.

Who do they call? GEM
Halabi may carp about ICE and GEM but he and New Action have been invisible while GEM/ICEers have been at numerous charter school co-location and school closing meetings supporting teachers and parents and building alliances. When they need support they call us. And we have been there for them.


Well, anyway, given all this, today he impressed me - for about 2 minutes. He got up to speak against a reso that everyone supported. It had language on credit recovery and some other issues and he was nervous but extremely articulate. I will get the video up when I can (I am very backed up on the videos). What he said is important to us in NYC.

And he did put up a very good piece critical of Weingarten on the first convention day.
AFT Convention in Seattle Day 1

Maybe there's some hope for some people in New Action. I respect and like New Action's Arjun Janah who today wrote a great poem about Bill Gates which I will post.

After burn
I was hanging with Stephen Sawchuk today and we had some good chats. I really didn't know his work 'till this week but I will take a closer look.

He was chosen to do a private interview with Gates post-speech. We talked about what he would ask and I am looking forward to seeing what he writes. Meanwhile follow his posts at: http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/teacherbeat/


I got to watch his computer while he went to meet with Gates. Maybe next time we switch and I interview Gates- hear that Janet Bass (who as AFT press chief was extremely gracious throughout the week- in case you didn't know I am here as press for The Wave - I think there is a Rockaway somewhere in the Pacific Northwest).

While I was baby sitting his computer I ended up in the midst of what looked suspiciously like a Unity Caucus meeting about voting in the AFT elections. I wasn't asked to leave as almost everyone was gracious - only Sandi March was nasty - but what do you expect? I was extremely pleased when Alan Lubin came over to say hello. Alan is one of the most respected union officials I have met. He was once Dist 32 rep and then Brooklyn boro chief. He is VP of NYSUT for quite a while. I had heard he was ill but he looked great. He just retired. No matter how much we all disagreed politically, Alan was always a mensch, never making things personal, always with a quip. It is funny but many of the old guard Unity people do not look at this as war. But I find many of the Unity relative newbies are rabid.


From two observers, one of them associated with the Chicago Teachers Union Twitter feed on Gates appearance at AFT convention

10 comments:

  1. FROM INSIDE THE UNITY CAUCUS:

    OH NO -BIG BARR MISTAKE!
    SO THE GUY WHO GOT HIS JOB BECAUSE HE LED THE CHANTS AT UFT RALLIES- AND BECAUSE RANDI WANTED TO SPLIT THE BLACK SUPPORT WHEN SHE RAN MICHELLE BODDEN OUT OF HER JOB---MADE A MAJOR MISTAKE ON THE UNION WEBSITE LAST WEEK.
    HE INVITED PEOPLE TO THE AFT PROGRESSIVE CAUCUS MEETINGS- A MAJOR NO-NO SINCE PROGRESSIVE IS A POLITICAL PARTY IN THE UNION AND HE IS NOT ALLOWED TO USE MEMBERS MONEY TO PROMOTE A CAUCUS.
    HAS ANYONE NOTICED? HE HAD TO CLEAR IT WITH MULGREW SINCE HE ALWAYS WAITS TO BE TOLD WHAT TO DO AND THE UFT NITWIT LAWYER- ZAHLER'S NEPHEW---- DIDNT TELL HIM HE WAS MAKING A MAJOR BLUNDER?
    THIS SHOWS HOW LITLE REGARD MULGREW HAS FOR THE MEMBERS AND THE LAW.
    MEMBERS CAN ASK FOR A REFUND OF THEIR DUES OVER THIS.

    ReplyDelete
  2. New Action is the biggest impediment there is to a unified and effective opposition, no matter what they do or say. Unless they give up their union-given jobs and positions, what happened in Chicago will never happen here.

    The "reforms" from Chicago, on the other hand, may come quite quickly, no matter what sort of lip service with which New Action "opposes" it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The Unity Caucus individual who broke that story should tell the press.

    Hearing about New Action in the summer is more than depressing. That New Action guy went to a bar in Seattle to bad mouth ICE. New Action not running against Mulgrew or Weingarten is a much bigger problem for opposition in NYC than ICE.

    ReplyDelete
  4. HE INVITED PEOPLE TO THE AFT PROGRESSIVE CAUCUS MEETINGS- A MAJOR NO-NO SINCE PROGRESSIVE IS A POLITICAL PARTY IN THE UNION AND HE IS NOT ALLOWED TO USE MEMBERS MONEY TO PROMOTE A CAUCUS.
    HAS ANYONE NOTICED? HE HAD TO CLEAR IT WITH MULGREW SINCE HE ALWAYS WAITS TO BE TOLD WHAT TO DO AND THE UFT NITWIT LAWYER- ZAHLER'S NEPHEW---- DIDNT TELL HIM HE WAS MAKING A MAJOR BLUNDER?

    ReplyDelete
  5. no matter what they do or say. Unless they give up their union-given jobs and positions, what happened in Chicago will never happen here.

    ReplyDelete
  6. No matter what you think of randi - give her "credit" for a brilliant stroke in buying off the chief opposition. Think if it - New Action at one time was getting almost a third of the vote. Even though they shrank to about 22% - betweem 10 and 12 thousand votes before the 2004 sellout to Unity, they still could win the 6 high school seats on their own without Unity support like they needed this time. Now how many votes do they get? More than ICE/TJC certainly, but still when you think of the potential given the deteriorating conditions and the infrastructure New Action had built, they could have developed into something dangerous to Unity. Instead ICE and TJC were forced to take on a role they were not suited for.

    But to have accomplished this they would have needed new leadership which in a top down org is almost impossible.

    ReplyDelete
  7. There is nothing wrong with what Leroy did---these delegates represent the UFT!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. WHY WONT MULGREW THE ANONYMOUS BLOGGER COME OUT OF THE CLOSET?
    LEGALLY, (A FOREIGN CONCEPT FOR MULGREW AND BARR) THE A.F.T. DELGATES DO NOT REPRESENT THE PROGRESSIVE CAUCUS AND THEREFORE BARR IS NOT ALLOWED TO USE UFT DUES TO PROMOTE A POLITICAL PARTY WITHIN THE UNION.
    PRETTY SIMPLE EVEN FOR MULGREW TO UNDERSTAND- YOU WOULLD HOPE!
    YOU ARE RIGHT MULGREW: BARR DIDNT DO IT- HE JUST SIGNED HIS NAME LIKE A GOOD SOLDIER; HE DOES NOTHING WITHOUT ASKING YOU.
    STOP USING THE MEMBERS MONEY FOR THE PROGRESSIVE/UNITY CAUCUS.

    ReplyDelete
  9. SANDI MARCH IS ALWAYS NASTY- SHE WAS BORN THAT WAY.
    ASK HER WHY SHE DIDNT KNOW THAT RUDY AND BLOOMBERG WERE CHEATING THE MEMBERS OUT OF THEIR PENSION BUCKS AND THE UFT HAD TO SUE ITSELF (UNION HAS THREE TRUSTEES ON THE TRS BOARD).

    ReplyDelete
  10. why don't you come out of the closet first?

    ReplyDelete

Comments are welcome. Irrelevant and abusive comments will be deleted, as will all commercial links. Comment moderation is on, so if your comment does not appear it is because I have not been at my computer (I do not do cell phone moderating). Or because your comment is irrelevant or idiotic.